
After two ex Manchester United players, Paul Ince and Roy Keane lost their jobs to Premier League clubs Blackburn and Sunderland respectively; a debate has started to form about whether ex-players can make the quick transition into club management.
Both managers had had experience in the lower leagues of football, both winning silverware, with Keane winning the championship, and Ince taking MK Dons to Wembley and winning the FA Trophy. Keane also had a years experience in the Premiership, keeping Sunderland up last year, but this season, when experiencing his first bout of serious pressure, it seems to have been too much for the fiery character.
Ince though, had no prior experience in the Premier League, and was given the task of managing a club who had developed into a top ten side under Mark Hughes. Perhaps making his tenure a hard act to follow, as he had to keep the momentum established by Hughes going, which he didn’t. After poor run of results, Ince had left the board with no choice but to severe ties with him.
Keane on the other hand, should have stayed, but due to his persona, he does not seem like the type of individual who would withstand abuse from his own supporters, and after leaked rumours talking of loss of communication in the dressing room, it shows that maybe Keane needs some more time to find his feet in football management.
The majority of pundits and managers seem to believe that managers, most particularly Ince, should have been given more time to turn things around at Blackburn. But in this day and age in football, everything is based on results, and although it may seem unfair, these results need to be established quickly. Poor runs of form which result in a club been sucked into the relegation zone will always cause a knee jerk reaction, as the thought of loosing out on lucrative money from being a to flight team will strike fear into club chairmen.
Other ex players who are managing include Mark Hughes (as mentioned previously, Steve Bruce, Gareth Southgate, and Tony Adams. All of which have had their fair share of pressure, but only time will tell who will survive in this cutthroat business that is the premier league.
Both managers had had experience in the lower leagues of football, both winning silverware, with Keane winning the championship, and Ince taking MK Dons to Wembley and winning the FA Trophy. Keane also had a years experience in the Premiership, keeping Sunderland up last year, but this season, when experiencing his first bout of serious pressure, it seems to have been too much for the fiery character.
Ince though, had no prior experience in the Premier League, and was given the task of managing a club who had developed into a top ten side under Mark Hughes. Perhaps making his tenure a hard act to follow, as he had to keep the momentum established by Hughes going, which he didn’t. After poor run of results, Ince had left the board with no choice but to severe ties with him.
Keane on the other hand, should have stayed, but due to his persona, he does not seem like the type of individual who would withstand abuse from his own supporters, and after leaked rumours talking of loss of communication in the dressing room, it shows that maybe Keane needs some more time to find his feet in football management.
The majority of pundits and managers seem to believe that managers, most particularly Ince, should have been given more time to turn things around at Blackburn. But in this day and age in football, everything is based on results, and although it may seem unfair, these results need to be established quickly. Poor runs of form which result in a club been sucked into the relegation zone will always cause a knee jerk reaction, as the thought of loosing out on lucrative money from being a to flight team will strike fear into club chairmen.
Other ex players who are managing include Mark Hughes (as mentioned previously, Steve Bruce, Gareth Southgate, and Tony Adams. All of which have had their fair share of pressure, but only time will tell who will survive in this cutthroat business that is the premier league.